1 RECORDED APPEARANCE

The Recast Remix

The hosts consider a six-role recast with a 2006 setting and similar-age casting constraint.

1game appearance
0explicit participant winners
0results needing restraint
0different recorded winners

High School Musical Part 1 ↗

Listen to the full High School Musical Part 1 episode ↗

Game / activity

The Recast Remix

Source excerpt ↗ 1:22:47

How this one works

How it works
  1. Replacement role count: 6; Period: 2006; Age constraint: roughly the same age; Reboot: False
  2. Nomination: once we've all said; Selection basis: them fight to the death,; Fight is hypothetical: True; Exact age not universal: True
  3. discussion and selection of a hypothetical fight winner for each role

RESULT STATUS

This one was not a competition.

Show 4 more contributions

RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE

Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:39:45

Recorded conversation

More of this contribution
  • Final state summary: Taylor: Cynthia Erivo; Ryan: Jonathan Groff; Gab: Stephanie Beatriz; Chad: Michael B. Jordan; Char: Kelly Cuoco; Troy bolden: Rihanna

Follow the round structure (6)

Taylor

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:23:25

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Taylor

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Taylor

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Rihanna

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Musicality claimed: True; Age fit claimed: True; Acting reference: Battleship; Toughness considered: True

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Reese Witherspoon

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 44; Fit: got the admin bit.; Singing not needed claimed: True

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Cynthia Erivo

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Not exactly 44 acknowledged: True; Prior unsubmitted choice: Reese Witherspoon; Prior choice changed before hearing duplicate: True

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:26:59

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Cynthia Erivo

More of this contribution
  • Adjudication method: It's two against one,

Ryan

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:27:15

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Ryan

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Ryan

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Jonathan Groff

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 40; Exact age match claimed: True

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Cole Scola

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: I mean, obviously he's not going to win in a fight.

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Daniel Radcliffe

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Age initially questioned: True; Role remains: Ryan; Age discussion: He's not quite 40, He was 36.

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:28:39

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Jonathan Groff

Round context
  • Rules: Proposed order: snake; Danny deferred to last: True

Gab

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:28:51

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Gab

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Gab

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Stephanie Beatrice

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Older than target acknowledged: True; Age ballpark claimed: True; Screen persona reference: Brooklyn Nine-Nine; Real voice fit: she is perfect for like a high school girl.

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Emma Stone

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 36; Self imposed exact age: True; Alternatives considered slim: True; Defense: Well, I just stick to the spirit of the game.

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Naya Rivera

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Prior audition claimed: Gabriela Montez; Reference: Glee

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:31:16

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Stephanie Beatrice

More of this contribution
  • Result qualification: Later confirmation: Stephanie Beatriz.; Earlier nomination spelling: Stephanie Beatrice.

Chad

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:31:45

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Chad

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Chad

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Rupert Grint

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 36; Unsubmitted backup: Kevin Durant; Backup described as: basketball player

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Michael B. Jordan

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Singing and dancing ability claimed: unknown; Acting assessment: great actor.; Earlier fame of own troy pick claimed: True; Possibly overpowered for role: True; Confident against other candidates in fight: True

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Joe Keery

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Singing claimed: True; Fight reservation reference: Stranger Things

RECORDED EXCHANGE

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Request: to make the call then; Remaining candidates: Michael B. Jordan Joe Keery

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:34:30

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Michael B. Jordan

Sharpay

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:34:46

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Sharpay

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Sharpay

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Rachel McAdams

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: but I think she's too old.

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Bryce Dallas Howard

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: I looked it up. She's in the right ballpark.

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Kaylee Cuoco

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 40; Star power claimed: True; Scrappy claimed: True; Unsubmitted fight alternative: Gal Gadot

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:36:09

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Kaylee Cuoco

More of this contribution
  • Adjudication method: Overall source framing: After death matches,; Local selection rationale: attitude fitting a Sharpay type; Earlier fight uncertainty expressed: True
  • Result qualification: Recap spelling: Kelly Cuoco.; Nomination spelling: Kaylee Cuoco.

Troy

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:36:21

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Prompt
Question / challenge

Task: nominate replacement; Role: Troy

More of this contribution
  • Prompt item: Troy

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Rihanna

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: Source claimed current age: 37; Gender bending acknowledged: True; Merits claimed: tough flexible ability to adapt; Limited exact age choices claimed: True; Unsubmitted backups: Tim Tebow Tom Felden Michael Cera

WHAT THEY BROUGHT

Recorded conversation

Aaron Tveit

More of this contribution
  • Answer qualification: I answered it on this podcast.

RECORDED EXCHANGE

Participant cited: Attribution unavailableSource excerpt ↗ 1:39:31

“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.

Rihanna

View source wording — how it was explained on the show
  • Adjudication method: discussion and selection of a hypothetical fight winner for each role
  • The celebrity selected for a role is a fictional casting outcome, not a podcaster’s competitive win.