Game / activity
Reverse Caricatures
How this one works
Premise
- Pick cartoon characters and identify real-world celebrities to play them in live action.
Final round
- Name a cartoon character for yourself; the others may offer alternatives.
Recorded activity context
The hosts propose real-world performers for cartoon characters, then reverse the premise by choosing cartoon roles for themselves.
RESULT STATUS
This one was not a competition.
See how they answered
Within the recorded rounds · 67 recorded contributions
Follow the round structure (4)
Round 1: The Simpsons
Source excerpt ↗ 31:32–37:24Casting live-action versions of Simpsons characters.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Homer → Jim Belushi
Casting pick: Homer → Jim Belushi.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Marge → Katey Sagal
Casting pick: Marge → Katey Sagal.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Bart → Haley Joel Osment
Casting pick: Bart → Haley Joel Osment.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Lisa → Shirley Temple
Casting pick: Lisa → Shirley Temple.
More of this contribution
- The Shirley Temple pick is reassigned from Maggie to Lisa.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Homer → David Harbour
Casting pick: Homer → David Harbour.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Homer → Tom Cruise
Casting pick: Homer → Tom Cruise.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Marge → Emma Stone
Casting pick: Marge → Emma Stone.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Marge → Kelly Macdonald
Casting pick: Marge → Kelly Macdonald.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Marge → Fran Drescher
Casting pick: Marge → Fran Drescher.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Bart → Macaulay Culkin
Casting pick: Bart → Macaulay Culkin.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Bart → young Adam Sandler
Casting pick: Bart → young Adam Sandler.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Lisa → Dakota Fanning
Casting pick: Lisa → Dakota Fanning.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Lisa → Tina Fey
Casting pick: Lisa → Tina Fey.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Maggie → Vin Diesel
Casting pick: Maggie → Vin Diesel.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ned Flanders → Tom Arnold
Casting pick: Ned Flanders → Tom Arnold.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ned Flanders → Bryan Cranston
Casting pick: Ned Flanders → Bryan Cranston.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ned Flanders → Jim Rash
Casting pick: Ned Flanders → Jim Rash.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Moe Szyslak → Gilbert Gottfried
Casting pick: Moe Szyslak → Gilbert Gottfried.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Marge → Bryan Cranston
Casting pick: Marge → Bryan Cranston. An aside about Cranston’s versatility, not a final cast choice.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
D’Arcy Carden mention
A speaker initially mistakes Kelly Macdonald for D’Arcy Carden while looking her up. This is not recorded as a casting pick.
RECORDED EXCHANGE
“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.
Stated Simpsons preferences
The discussion explicitly favors Ryan’s Homer pick and Curtis’s Bart pick, and praises Tina Fey for Lisa. The Ned Flanders remark “Brian won that one too” is ambiguous between an actor name and a participant; no selected Flanders actor is assigned.
Round 2: Toy Story 2
Source excerpt ↗ 37:24–42:05Casting Toy Story 2 characters.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Woody → Jon Hamm
Casting pick: Woody → Jon Hamm.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Woody → Josh Brolin
Casting pick: Woody → Josh Brolin.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Buzz Lightyear → Josh Brolin
Casting pick: Buzz Lightyear → Josh Brolin.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Woody → Michael B. Jordan
Casting pick: Woody → Michael B. Jordan.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Buzz Lightyear → Kevin James
Casting pick: Buzz Lightyear → Kevin James.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Buzz Lightyear → Buzz Aldrin
Casting pick: Buzz Lightyear → Buzz Aldrin.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Buzz Lightyear → John Cena
Casting pick: Buzz Lightyear → John Cena.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mr. Potato Head → Jason Alexander
Casting pick: Mr. Potato Head → Jason Alexander.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mrs. Potato Head → Wendy the Snapple lady
Casting pick: Mrs. Potato Head → Wendy the Snapple lady.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Jessie → Lindsay Lohan
Casting pick: Jessie → Lindsay Lohan.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Jessie → Reba McEntire
Casting pick: Jessie → Reba McEntire.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Jessie → Mila Kunis
Casting pick: Jessie → Mila Kunis.
RECORDED EXCHANGE
“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.
Toy Story 2: closing cast
Woody: Jon Hamm; Buzz Lightyear: John Cena; Jessie: Lindsay Lohan; Mr. Potato Head: Jason Alexander.
Round 3: Mario characters
Source excerpt ↗ 42:06–48:22Casting Mario characters.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mario → Danny DeVito
Casting pick: Mario → Danny DeVito.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Luigi → Larry David
Casting pick: Luigi → Larry David.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mario → Danny DeVito
Casting pick: Mario → Danny DeVito.
More of this contribution
- Changes the second Danny DeVito pick to Luis Guzmán.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mario → Eddie Murphy
Casting pick: Mario → Eddie Murphy.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mario → Tom Cruise
Casting pick: Mario → Tom Cruise.
More of this contribution
- The proposer keeps Eddie Murphy instead.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Luigi → Michael Richards
Casting pick: Luigi → Michael Richards.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Mario → Luis Guzmán
Casting pick: Mario → Luis Guzmán.
More of this contribution
- Replaces the second Danny DeVito pick; Shaq remains Luigi.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Luigi → Shaq
Casting pick: Luigi → Shaq.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Princess Peach → Sarah Michelle Gellar
Casting pick: Princess Peach → Sarah Michelle Gellar.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Princess Daisy → Kaitlin Olson
Casting pick: Princess Daisy → Kaitlin Olson.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Princess Peach → Betty White
Casting pick: Princess Peach → Betty White.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Princess Peach → Ellie Kemper
Casting pick: Princess Peach → Ellie Kemper.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Princess Daisy → Alison Brie
Casting pick: Princess Daisy → Alison Brie.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Wario → Jack Black
Casting pick: Wario → Jack Black.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Wario → James Gandolfini
Casting pick: Wario → James Gandolfini.
More of this contribution
- Receives an initial concession, but the closing recap chooses Jack Black.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Waluigi → John Mulaney
Casting pick: Waluigi → John Mulaney.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Donkey Kong → Mark Henry
Casting pick: Donkey Kong → Mark Henry.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Donkey Kong → Robin Williams
Casting pick: Donkey Kong → Robin Williams.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Donkey Kong → Will Ferrell
Casting pick: Donkey Kong → Will Ferrell.
RECORDED EXCHANGE
“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.
Mario: closing cast
Mario: Danny DeVito; Luigi: Shaq; Princess Peach: Ellie Kemper; Princess Daisy: Kaitlin Olson; Wario: Jack Black; Waluigi: John Mulaney; Donkey Kong: Robin Williams.
More of this contribution
- The Donkey Kong choice is immediately challenged.
Round context
- The hosts disagree about duplicate picks.
Final round: Cartoon versions of the hosts
Source excerpt ↗ 48:22–52:09Choosing cartoon characters for the hosts.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Brad → Gonzo
Self-pick: Brad → Gonzo.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Brad → Gonzo
Casting pick: Brad → Gonzo.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Brad → Johnny Bravo
Casting pick: Brad → Johnny Bravo.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Brad → Rick Sanchez
Casting pick: Brad → Rick Sanchez.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Curtis → Hank Hill
Self-pick: Curtis → Hank Hill.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Curtis → Kermit the Frog
Casting pick: Curtis → Kermit the Frog.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Curtis → CatDog
Casting pick: Curtis → CatDog.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Curtis → CatDog
Casting pick: Curtis → CatDog.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ryan → Fozzie Bear
Self-pick: Ryan → Fozzie Bear.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ryan → Doug Funnie
Casting pick: Ryan → Doug Funnie.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ryan → Sterling Archer
Casting pick: Ryan → Sterling Archer.
RECORDED EXCHANGE
“Participant cited” identifies a contributor, not the speaker of every word in this excerpt. It may include other participants’ replies or reactions.
Final host cartoon choices
Brad is Gonzo, Curtis is Kermit the Frog and Ryan is Sterling Archer.
RECORDED ANSWER / CHOICE
Ryan’s retrospective Gonzo reference
After naming Fozzie Bear for himself, Ryan says that is how he arrived at Gonzo for Brad. This supports Ryan having considered Gonzo, but does not identify the earlier speaker who also proposed Gonzo and Johnny Bravo.
View source wording — how it was explained on the show
- Four casting rounds; no overall winner or score is stated.